The Best Whiskey for Whiskey Sour
Our Top 3 Choices
A Whiskey Sour is a classic cocktail that balances the warm flavors of whiskey with the freshness of citrus, smoothened out with simple syrup. While there are many ways to customize this drink, the choice of whiskey plays a crucial role in the final flavor. When choosing the best whiskey for Whiskey Sour, it’s important to consider both taste and aroma, as well as the what kind of flavor profile you prefer. For the best experience, we recommend using bourbon. Bourbon’s natural sweetness, mild spice, and round, balanced character make it the ideal base for a well-rounded Whiskey Sour.
Using rye whiskey in a Whiskey Sour will result in a spicier, more peppery cocktail. While this can yield an exciting variation, it may overshadow the citrus freshness that defines a great Whiskey Sour. On the other hand, using a smoky Scotch can drastically alter the drink, as smoke can easily overpower the fresh citrus flavors. That’s why we’ve selected three of the best bourbons to create the perfect Whiskey Sour—each of these bourbons is versatile and works beautifully in other bourbon-forward cocktails as well.
Once you’ve found your Whiskey of choice, check out our Whiskey Sour Recipe!
Our Choices for Best Whiskey for Whiskey Sour
We carefully select all recommendations on World of Mixology. When you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission, which allows us to continue to produce content. We carefully consider which retailers we collaborate with based on their service and price, so you can be sure of the quality when buying through our links.
Our collaborator in Denmark, Barlife.dk, has price guarantee so you can get the best prices when buying through our links.
Buffalo Trace
The Best Whiskey for a Well-Rounded Whiskey Sour
Buffalo Trace bourbon is our top recommendation for a Whiskey Sour because of its well-balanced profile of caramel sweetness, soft spice, and a rich, smooth finish. This bourbon blends perfectly with fresh lemon juice and simple syrup, creating a cocktail that is both complex and approachable.
Taste
Buffalo Trace offers a smooth, slightly sweet flavor with notes of caramel, vanilla, and toffee. It has just enough spice from the oak aging to add depth, without overwhelming the bright citrus flavors of the cocktail.
Aroma
The aroma is rich with hints of brown sugar, vanilla, and light oak spice, making it a great choice for a balanced drink. When mixed into the cocktail, these aromas enhance the drink’s complexity while maintaining balance.
Maker’s Mark
A Smooth and Sweet Alternative
Maker’s Mark is an excellent second choice for a Whiskey Sour, thanks to its wheated bourbon mash bill, which results in a softer, sweeter profile. This makes it a great option for those who prefer a milder, smoother cocktail with less spice.
Taste
Maker’s Mark is known for its rich caramel and vanilla notes, with a buttery smoothness that blends beautifully into the cocktail. It brings a slightly sweeter and more rounded character to the cocktail, making it very easy to drink.
Aroma
The nose is filled with warm vanilla, honey, and toasted oak. These aromas create an approachable experience, which translates beautifully into a well-balanced cocktail.
Woodford Reserve
A Complex and Spicier Option
Woodford Reserve takes third place on our list, offering a more complex and layered experience for those who enjoy a Whiskey Sour with added depth. This bourbon has a higher rye content than Maker’s Mark, adding a touch of spice while maintaining a balanced and smooth profile.
Taste
Woodford Reserve brings a rich combination of dried fruit, dark chocolate, and spice, with hints of toasty oak and caramel. This complexity makes for a slightly bolder drink while still allowing the citrus and sweetness to shine through.
Aroma
The nose offers notes of dried fruit, cocoa, cinnamon, and toasted oak. These elements works well in the cocktail, making it an excellent choice for those who appreciate a more complex bourbon experience.
Each of these bourbons brings something unique to a Whiskey Sour, but all three share a well-rounded character that makes them ideal for this cocktail. Buffalo Trace provides the best overall balance, Maker’s Mark delivers smooth sweetness, and Woodford Reserve adds a touch of spice and complexity. Whether you prefer a classic, a sweeter, or a spicier take on the cocktail, you can’t go wrong with these choices.
Try them all and discover which one makes your perfect Whiskey Sour!
If you are looking to go beyond the whiskey sour, check out our cocktail recipes:
Social Media
- All
- Highball
- Juleps
- Sour
- Spirit-Forward
